April 25, 2024

My Student Loan Debt is unmanageable. Can I discharge it through bankruptcy?

Prior to October 7, 1998, student loan debt that had been in repayment for more than seven years from the date of bankruptcy filing was dischargeable. That seven year provision was eliminated with the bankruptcy law change in 1998. Student loans are now non-dischargeable under Title 11 U.S.C. Section 523 (a)(8) of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code unless a case of undue hardship exists.

It is very hard to qualify for the undue hardship provision. Most courts only grant a petition for undue hardship if the debtor is elderly, has high medical costs, and supports at least one dependent.

For those debtors who do not qualify for the undue hardship provision, there is one other option for discharging student loan debts. A new option for repaying student loan debt was established alongside the College Cost Reduction and Access Act of 2007. The Act created the Public Service Loan Forgiveness Program, in which public service workers can make student loan payments for ten years, at which point the remaining principle and interest will be fully discharged. Better yet, the amount of payment for ten years will be income-contingent or income-based. The program extends to a broad number of public service jobs including, government, military, police, fire, non-profit employees, public school teachers, and social workers, just to name a few.

Not all student loans qualify for this program. However, if the debtor’s loans do not qualify, they may be able to consolidate into a qualifying loan.

Another issue with this program is that it may create forgiveness of indebtedness income which may be taxed by the IRS. It is still unclear whether or not the IRS will exempt this program from income tax by 2017, when the first loans under this program will be forgiven.

To find out more information about the Public Service Loan Forgiveness Program, you should visit http://www.finaid.org/loans/publicservice.phtml or http://loanconsolidation.ed.gov/ or contact the Department of Education at 1-800-557-7372.

 

[UPDATE:  New student loan forgiveness programs have been added since this article was written.  Do some internet searching on “student loan forgiveness” to find out what is available.]

What does a “discharge” in bankruptcy mean?

One of the reasons people file bankruptcy is to get a “discharge” of their debt. A discharge is a court order which states that you do not have to pay the debts. Some debts cannot be discharged. For example, you cannot discharge debts for:

most taxes (however, income taxes for which a return has been on file for a long time can, in some circumstances, be discharged);
child support or alimony;
student loans;
court fines and criminal restitution; and
personal injury caused by driving drunk or under the influence of drugs.

The discharge only applies to debts that arose before the date you filed. Anything that you incur after filing becomes your personal responsibility and is not discharged.

It is important to list all your property and debts in your bankruptcy schedules. If a debt is not listed, there is a possibility that it may not be considered for discharge.

You can only receive a chapter 7 discharge once every eight years.

Some creditors hold a secured claim (for example, the bank that holds the mortgage on your house or the loan company that has a lien on your car). You do not have to pay a secured claim if the debt is discharged, but if you wish to keep the property (the house or the car), you will need to keep making the payments.

I owe money to the IRS, can I discharge that when I file bankruptcy?

There answer to that question is that it depends.  There are two tests that have to be met.

1.  Has the return been on file long enough?

Were all of the related returns (i.e. all your tax returns for the tax years for which these taxes are owed) filed on a timely basis, and has it been 3 years since the last date such returns were due including all extensions? [Note: This means that for tax year 2006, the return with extension would be due Oct. 15th, 2007, and you’d have to wait three years from that date.  But if Oct 15th fell on a weekend, then the return would actually be due Oct 16th or 17th, and you’d have to wait three years from that date.  It’s very tricky. ]

2.  Has the amount owed to the IRS been settled/assessed for at least two years?

If your return was ever challenged or if the amount you owed to the IRS was ever unclear for any reason, then you must also wait at least two years from the time the amount owed to the IRS was finally assessed.

 

If the answer to both questions above is yes, then you can file bankruptcy and discharge the IRS debt. If the answer is no, you can either (a) wait until it has been a long enough period of time and then file bankruptcy, or (b) try an “Offer in Compromise” now and see what happens.

You can find info on Offers in Compromise on www.irs.gov. Or you can hire a tax dispute attorney, to help you try to negotiate a settlement with the IRS. If you decide to go this route, be sure you hire a reputable attorney or CPA and not one of the Fly-By-Night organizations that claim to be able to handle tax problems.

Something to keep in mind – If some of this tax debt is for monies withheld from employees’ paychecks that you failed to forward to the IRS, then the debt may not be dischargeable, and such debt may pierce through a corporation or LLC entity and attach personally to the business owner.

What is exempt property?

Exempt property is property that can not be taken from you by your creditors. In other words, it is property that is exempt from levy by creditors. Even hundreds of years ago in England, where our legal system was developed, debtors were able to keep the shirts on their backs. Today the law is more generous. The idea behind exemptions is that debtors get to keep the minimal property necessary to sustain themselves and their livelihoods. So, in most states, the list of exempt property includes things like clothing and personal effects, tools of the trade, one vehicle per driver (up to a limited dollar amount of value), your home (up to a limited dollar amount of value in most states), retirement accounts, and life insurance policies.

After hearing that list, most people say, “That covers everything I own. What kinds of things are not exempt?” Common examples of non-exempt property which CAN be taken by creditors include boats, RV’s additional real estate (i.e. real estate other than your homestead), stocks/bonds, ownership of a business, expensive jewelry and cash in a checking or savings account.

Each state has its own list of which types of property are on the list and what is on the list can vary greatly from state to state. And there are several exceptional types of debts, such as child support and taxes, that can allow creditors to reach even otherwise exempt property.

Also, if a debtor voluntarily places himself into bankruptcy, additional federal laws come into play which can vary what is exempt and what is not.

Pay Day Loan Lenders and Threats of Criminal Prosecution for Hot Checks

Pay day loan lenders are often the most aggressive about collecting.  I routinely hear about pay day loan lenders violating debt collection laws.  They commonly ask you to make out postdated checks for them when you borrow the money.  Then, when they deposit those checks later, if one bounces, they call and threaten to report you to the police for writing a hot check.  Sometimes, they even say “You could go to jail for writing that hot check.”  This is not true.  You can’t be convicted of a crime without having some level of intent (i.e. a state of mind involving some level of desire or wilful disregard towards commission of the crime).  Writing a post-dated check is not a crime.  And having less money in the future than you expected is also not a crime.

These threats by debt collectors are illegal.  It is illegal to threaten criminal prosecution to collect a debt, especially when no crime has been committed!  If you have a writing or recording of these threats, you should visit with an attorney about the possibility of filing a lawsuit against the debt collector for illegal debt collection practices under the Federal Debt Collection Practices Act (which applies in all states) or the Texas Debt Collection Practices Act (which applies only in Texas).

Everything I have stated above, and everything I write on this blog, assumes that the acts took place in Texas and Texas law applies. I can’t say for certain, but I would imagine that other states are more or less the same with regard to their hot check writing laws.  After all, it would violate common sense, basic human decency, and the United States Constitution to imprison someone who had no level of intent towards commission of a crime.  Check with your local bankruptcy lawyer.

Good summary of when you can file Chapter 7 Bankruptcy even if you fail the means test – the key is “special circumstances”

Read the whole article by Lori Patton here.  It’s a good overview of how bankruptcy lawyers think through the means test.
http://www.nationalbankruptcyforum.com/bankruptcy-myths/does-failure-to-pass-the-means-test-automatically-cut-off-chapter-7-eligibility/

Here is a small excerpt:

After all necessary income and expenses are plugged in, my software gives me either a green smiley face or a yellow frowny face at the bottom indicating whether going through the long form got us under median. Green is good. Yellow is not good. When I still have yellow after going through long form I still need to ask a few questions before giving up and telling a client they are ineligible for filing a Chapter 7 Bankruptcy. This is because we still have a couple escape hatches in 11 USC 707(b) “special circumstances” and “totality of the circumstances”.

Examples of “Special Circumstances” are given in the Code: “such as a serious medical condition or a call or order to active duty in the Armed Forces…  I will tell you now that a child needing braces or getting ready to go to college is not going to fly. A car on its last leg and the need to replace it has worked for me in the past.

“Totality of the Circumstances” is defined in the Code as “whether the totality of the circumstances of the debtor’s financial situation demonstrates abuse.” This is nice and vague, which gives us more options. Obvious situations that fit would be lost employment, reduction in income that is not expected to recover soon, divorce, recently ordered domestic support (child support or alimony) that was not factored into the means test, as well as the fact that the income calculation might include 401K or retirement draws, or other “nonrecurring income” that is not reasonably expected in the foreseeable future.

It is all so individually specific to each particular client that I hesitate to tell you that something will or will not work in your case.

If I see either a special circumstance or a “totality of the circumstances” event, and there is no other good reason to do a Chapter 13 (hey! Another good article topic!), then I will file the case as a Chapter 7, despite the yellow frowny face on my screen. What will happen then is I will get a phone call or email from a paralegal at the United States Trustee’s office about the filing and requesting support for the filing. I will then quickly email to them all the documentation and support I have. The paralegal for the UST will likely come to the creditor’s meeting (about a month after filing) and ask the clients some or a lot of questions about the special circumstances or change in circumstances. They are not being mean, but they have to get those answers recorded so they can justify to their bosses in Washington D.C. why they didn’t throw the book at us.
Filing a Chapter 7 when the presumption of abuse arises because of not passing the means test makes getting through it tougher, but not necessarily impossible. Another option to seriously consider, and is sometimes necessary, is waiting until the six month average is diluted.

How long does it take for the bank to foreclose on my house?

Answer:  On average it takes more than a year.

Source:

“The average loan in foreclosure—the process typically starts when a loan becomes 90 days past due and a bank files a complaint—had been in default for 492 days.”

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703865004575648900250047766.html?mod=WSJ_hp_mostpop_read

New Debtors Prisons?

This article from the Wall Street Journal seems to indicate that people are being sent to jail for failing to pay debts.  I practice law in Texas, and I know that in Texas a person can not be jailed for failing to pay a debt.  However, people can be jailed for failing to comply with a court order, such as an order to appear in court at a hearing, or to hand over certain documents requested by the creditor.  Most states allow garnishment of wages (Texas does not), so I guess in most states you could be jailed for failing to follow a court order to hand over a percentage of your wages.  But, to my knowledge, no state allows people to be jailed just for not paying debts.  I think there would be a Constitutional problem with that.

 

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704396504576204553811636610.html?mod=WSJ_hp_editorsPicks_3

Terms of Use - This website and all contents copyright 2011

Do not rely on this website for making decisions regarding bankruptcy. This website is intended for general information purposes only, and does not create an attorney - client relationship.